Part 1: Why So Many U.S. Owners Choose S-Corporations

🔎 Why So Many U.S. Owners Choose S-Corporations — The Real Tax Advantage Behind “Reasonable Salary + Distributions”

For many small and mid-sized business owners in the U.S., “S-Corporation” is the magic word they hear from CPAs and tax planners.
It’s not just a trendy label — when used correctly, an S-Corp can combine limited liability protection, pass-through taxation, and meaningful FICA savings compared to a default LLC or sole proprietorship.
In this Part 1 overview, we’ll walk through what an S-Corporation really is, how it differs from an LLC and C-Corp, where the actual tax savings come from, and when the structure may not be a good fit.

1️⃣ What Is an S-Corporation in the U.S. Tax System?

First important point: an S-Corporation (S-Corp) is not a special type of corporation formed at the state level.
It is a tax status under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code. Legally, you still form a regular corporation (or in many cases, an LLC), and then you elect to be treated as an S-Corporation for federal tax purposes by filing Form 2553.

In most years, an S-Corp does not pay regular federal corporate income tax the way a C-Corporation does. Instead, the company files an information return (Form 1120-S) and passes its income, deductions, credits, and other items through to the shareholders’ personal Form 1040 via Schedule K-1.

There are, however, a few situations where an S-Corp can still face tax at the corporate level — for example:

• Built-in gains tax on appreciated assets when a former C-Corporation converts to S-Corp status and sells those assets during the 5-year recognition period, taxed at the 21% corporate rate.
• Excess net passive income tax when an S-Corp with C-Corporation earnings and profits has too much passive investment income.
• LIFO recapture tax when a C-Corporation using LIFO inventory converts to S-Corp status.

These special taxes are mainly aimed at C-Corps converting to S-Corps with built-in appreciation or large passive investments, and are covered in much more detail in professional materials like S Corporation Taxes & Credits (Course #3330C).

2️⃣ How S-Corporations Are Taxed (Big Picture)

On the surface, an S-Corp return looks similar to a partnership return:

• The S-Corp files Form 1120-S each year.
• The company issues Schedule K-1 to each shareholder, showing that shareholder’s share of income, loss, deductions, and credits.
• Shareholders report those items on their individual Form 1040, regardless of whether the S-Corp actually distributes cash.

The crucial twist is in the employment tax side:

• Shareholders who actively work in the business must usually be treated as W-2 employees and paid a reasonable salary.
• That salary is subject to FICA taxes (Social Security & Medicare), just like any employee.
• But distributions (profit paid out on top of salary) are generally not subject to self-employment tax or FICA if properly structured.

This salary-plus-distribution model is where many small-business owners see meaningful savings compared to being taxed as a sole proprietor or default LLC.

3️⃣ S-Corp vs LLC vs C-Corp — Key Differences

🧩 Legal Entity vs Tax Election

Many owners confuse “LLC vs S-Corp” as if they were apples and oranges. In reality:

• LLC is a state-law legal entity that can be taxed as:
  • Disregarded entity (single-member, treated like a sole proprietor),
  • Partnership (multi-member),
  • C-Corporation, or
  • S-Corporation (if it qualifies and files Form 2553).
• S-Corporation is purely a tax status — a domestic corporation or LLC that has made the S election.

💰 Self-Employment Tax vs Payroll Tax

• Sole proprietors / default LLCs generally pay self-employment tax (15.3%) on all net earnings from self-employment.
• S-Corp owners-employees pay FICA only on their W-2 salary (Social Security up to the annual wage base, plus Medicare tax). Distributions are usually not subject to SE tax if properly structured.
• C-Corps also pay FICA on wages, but corporate profits are taxed again when distributed as dividends (classic double taxation).

📑 Ownership & Stock Rules

S-Corps have stricter rules than LLCs:

• Maximum of 100 shareholders.
• Only one class of stock (economic rights must be identical for all shares).
• Only eligible shareholders: generally U.S. individuals, certain trusts, and estates. No nonresident aliens, most entities, or partnerships as shareholders.

These rules make S-Corps more rigid than LLCs, but also make the tax results more predictable and easier to model for planning purposes.

4️⃣ Where the Real FICA Savings Come From

The headline benefit people chase with S-Corps is “FICA savings.” Here’s a simplified example to see how it works in practice.

This is why advisors often start talking about S-Corps when a business owner’s net profit is consistently above a certain level (commonly around $70,000–$80,000 of profit before owner compensation, sometimes higher depending on the situation).

The trade-off is that the S-Corp must:

• Run formal payroll (with withholding and payroll tax filings),
• Pay reasonable compensation to owner-employees, and
• Maintain good books and corporate formalities.

If the IRS believes your salary is unreasonably low, it can reclassify distributions as wages and assess additional FICA tax, penalties, and interest — a common S-Corp audit issue.

5️⃣ When an S-Corporation May Not Be a Good Fit

Despite the potential savings, S-Corps are not a one-size-fits-all solution. Situations where an S-Corp may be less attractive include:

• Very low or unstable profits: If your profit after paying yourself a reasonable wage is small, FICA savings may not cover the added compliance cost.
• High state-level taxes or fees: Some states impose minimum taxes or special fees on corporations and LLCs that can eat into savings.
• Need for complex capital-raising structures: If you want multiple classes of stock, preferred returns, or investors who are nonresident aliens or entities, an S-Corp may not work.
• Existing C-Corporation with large built-in gains: Converting to an S-Corp may trigger exposure to the built-in gains tax (21% corporate rate on appreciated assets sold within 5 years of conversion). :contentReference[oaicite:1]{index=1}
• High passive investment income with C-Corp E&P: S-Corps with C-Corporation earnings and profits can face an additional tax on excess passive income and even risk termination of S status if the problem continues. :contentReference[oaicite:2]{index=2}

That’s why a proper S-Corp analysis should always look at both income tax and employment tax, plus state rules and your long-term exit strategy.

6️⃣ Practical FAQs from Small-Business Owners

7️⃣ Official IRS Resources for S-Corporations

8️⃣ Related EA Tax Guide Articles

🔝 Back to Top